This ludicrous spectacle, carried out before 90 spectators at the Al-Muktafi Billah Shah Mosque, flagrantly violates the principles of compassion, justice and human dignity that Islam so profoundly upholds.

Affendi’s ‘crime’: A miscarriage of justice

Affendi was punished for repeated khalwat. How they verified his intentions and punished him remains a question.

For this, he was sentenced to six lashes of the cane, a RM4,000 (800 EUR) fine, and the looming threat of six months in jail if he cannot pay.

This is not justice. It is state-sanctioned cruelty. A man struggling to provide for his family has been publicly humiliated and broken by a system that preys on the vulnerable under the guise of morality.

Where is the compassion?

Islam teaches compassion, discretion and a commitment to protecting human dignity.

Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) warned against exposing others’ private faults and emphasised forgiveness over punishment.

Yet here we are, desecrating these sacred values by transforming personal missteps into public humiliation. A man’s private life has been laid bare and his dignity ripped away – not in the name of justice, but as a ridiculous spectacle to satisfy a version of an interpretation of Islamic law.

Futility and cruelty of public caning

Public caning does not deter wrongdoing. It amplifies trauma, entrenches social stigma, and perpetuates cycles of humiliation and psychological harm.

Research consistently shows that such punitive measures fail to rehabilitate and instead create lasting scars – both physical and emotional.

Worse, these punishments overwhelmingly target the poor and disenfranchised, exposing the systemic inequities that plague our justice system.

Studies have shown that public shaming often results in mental health issues like depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

Behavioural psychology research also highlights that punitive measures fail to produce long-term behavioural changes. Instead, they foster social withdrawal and a likelihood of reverting to previous behaviours.

Moreover, trauma from public punishments affects not just the offender but also witnesses, leading to cycles of harm within the community.

Comparative studies on criminal justice systems emphasise the effectiveness of rehabilitation-focused approaches over punitive measures. This growing body of evidence highlights the futility and cruelty of public caning as a deterrent or corrective measure.

Misinterpreting Islamic law

Let us be clear: khalwat is not a crime under Islamic hudud law.

Islam reserves hudud punishments for specific offences with strict evidentiary standards to protect the innocent.

Khalwat does not meet these criteria, nor does it constitute a crime with tangible societal harm.

By criminalising private conduct, the state has overreached, turning personal discretion into public transgression and trampling on the Islamic principles of mercy and justice.

Malaysia’s regressive turn

While nations like Saudi Arabia are abandoning such draconian practices, Malaysia is regressing, cementing its reputation as a nation that prioritises authoritarian control over genuine moral and societal progress.

Public caning in mosques – a place of sanctuary and peace – corrupts the sanctity of worship with violence and shame. It leaves an indelible mark not just on the individuals punished, but on our national conscience.

Is this the Malaysia we want?

Is this the Malaysia we aspire to build? A nation where cruelty and humiliation are paraded as justice? A society where the poor and powerless are disproportionately punished while the privileged walk free?

True justice demands empathy, fairness and evidence-based solutions – not the medieval theatrics of public punishment.

Call for reform

Terengganu and all Malaysian states repeal laws that criminalise personal sins and enforce degrading punishments like public caning.

Instead, focus on approaches rooted in counselling, education and rehabilitation without detention – methods that honour the values of Islam and the dignity of everyone in Malaysia.

Uphold the spirit of Islam

With a new year upon us, let us chart a new course – a path of mercy, justice and humanity that reflects Islam’s teachings.

Anything less is a betrayal of our faith, our Federal Constitution and our shared humanity. – SIS

---

Sisters in Islam

Click here to subscribe to ESSF newsletters in English and or French.